What Was Your First Encounter With 'Rule 34'?

Ah, Rule 34, the magical internet phenomenon that opened the eyes of so many unsuspecting weeblets when they googled their favorite anime that one time, so long ago. In today’s post, we’ll explore where this internet meme came from and whether or not sexy fan art of our favorite characters negatively affected our childhood!

Great news! J-List has started our Pre-Black Friday Sale, giving everyone an automatic 15% off all in-stock items shipping from Japan (except for 2025 calendars). Now is the perfect time to pick up those special naughty items you’ve had your eye on, or stock up on ero lotion, or browse our in-stock figures. Browse all our products here!

Sexy fan-created art has always existed, going back to the days of Tijuana Bibles in the 1920s and 30s. These short comics parodied the popular newspaper comics of the day, like Blondie, Little Orphan Annie and Dick Tracy.

In the anime era, a major turning point in the awareness that sexy parody art of existing anime characters was a thing was Sailor Moon and the Seven Ballz. This was a commercial hentai video that went on sale in 2000. The creators advertised in anime and toy magazines of the day, with many unsuspecting fans going online to buy the video, not knowing that it was porn. The blowback from parents helped cause the demise of great toy magazines like Wizard and ToyFare.

What is Rule 34?

The meme of “Rule 34” originated in a now-forgotten webcomic on August 13, 2003, stating that, “If you can imagine it, there is porn of it. No exceptions.” It was widely spread by this XKCD comic, and the rest was history.

The term certainly summed up what the internet was becoming in the early 2000s: a place where every kind of sexual thing imaginable could be found via the budding image boards that were cropping up everywhere. Want to see popular characters in a sexual embrace? How about “yuri shipping” involving any two female characters? You can even find your favorite Haruhi characters, but gender-bent! It was all out there, waiting to be found.

Rule 34 Is Important to Modern Fandom

A healthy fanbase creating sexy art of the characters they love is important for that fandom to flourish. Before I start a new anime, I’ll often browse various image boards to see what sexy art fans have made with the characters. If there’s a large body of parody art, as there was with the Princess Connect! Re:Dive community, I know there’ll be lots of cool fans to potentially connect with when enjoying a new show.

But if there’s almost no fan art or doujins, perhaps because the anime is based on a social game whose content is tightly controlled by the IP holders, it’s a sign the show isn’t hitting with fans as it should.

What are the most popular parody products on J-List? Browse the link here!

When the reboot of Space Battleship Yamato was announced, I was nervous because there were very few females in the 1974 original. How could you tell a compelling story that modern fans would respond to? The creators smartly switched the gender of several characters and added a few new ones, allowing for more storylines and drama in the story. This allowed for the kind of Rule 34 fan art expected of a modern anime fandom and also created a market for sexy figures. Everybody wins!

What do J-List Customers Say about Rule 34?

I asked J-List’s customers of culture about their first experiences with Rule 34 on the internet and whether it ruined their perception of beloved characters growing up. Let’s see what responses I got!

Has Rule 34 ever ruined a cherished childhood for me? Don’t you mean ‘improved’?

Ruined? Nope!

Konosuba and My Hero Academia hentai are unironically better than Konosuba and MHA themselves. [artist link]

Nope. Oftentimes, Rule 34 made it better. >:3

For a small second, yeah, it ruined things a little. But afterward, it made me like the show more.

Nope. I know they’re not canon to the original series, and I treat them as visual fan fiction.

Bishoujo Agent Nakadashi Bukkake J List List 53

J-List stocks all the best parody ero products from Japan, from doujins to JAV productions to awesome ero toys. Browse here!

More Reactions to Rule 34!

Ruined? No. With the trend of endless reboots of our favorite shows and movies, with ugly redesigns and cringe dialog, the Rule 34 stuff often feels like a more faithful sequel. [sauce]

The first show to be ruined for me was Teen Titans. I ignored all the fan art for the longest time until finally embracing it a few years later.

If you want to continue eating Frosted Flakes, DO NOT EVER Google Tony the Tiger. Don’t even Google him out of curiosity now that you’ve read my tweet here. I’m warning you, JUST DON’T DO IT!! I’m scarred for life whenever I walk down the cereal aisle at Walmart.

Thanks for reading this blog post about the internet phenomenon of Rule 34 and what it’s meant to the fans who grew up with it over the past two decades. How do you feel about sexy fan art of popular characters? Tell us in the comments below!